Clomid vs Letrozole: The Last Words

award winning fertility doctor new york city

 

Hello Everyone!

Today I will conclude the entries on Letrazol and Clomid, emphasizing the warnings related to letrazole.

“Femara* (the trade name for letrozole) is contraindicated and should not be used in women who may become pregnant, during pregnancy and/or while breastfeeding, because there is a potential risk of harm to the mother and the fetus, including risk of fetal malformations.”

Who says so? Novartis, the company that makes the drug, put out this warning.

There are 2 elements to this statement. First and accurately, the drug has been shown to cause malformations in mice and rats when given in low doses during pregnancy. If is for this reason that we all believe that giving it to pregnant women is not indicated. Clomid also carries a warning that it is not to be used in pregnancy for fear of birth defects, although the potential for defects seems to be lower than for Femara. Nonetheless, Clomid carries a warning.

The second element has to do with taking the drug before pregnancy, as in the case of induction of ovulation. In 2006, the company issued a statement to physicians specifically stating that Femara is not indicated for use in the induction of ovulation.

How did this second statement from Novartis come ot be? In 2005 a very short abstract was presented at a scientific meeting showing the birth defect rate was higher in 150 women who took Femara as compared to the general population. That’s 150 births, not 150 birth defects. Now, no one wants to ignore important birth defect data, however 7 birth defects in 150 women is just too small a group to rely on. Based on this one preliminary study, Novartis quickly issued the warning to physicians.

Soon after the Novartis letter, another physician, Dr Tulandi, examined pregnancy outcome of 911 babies conceived after Clomid or letrozole treatment in infertile women. Here is the data directly quoted from the writings of Dr.Tulandi. “Overall, congenital malformations and chromosomal abnormalities were found in 14 of 514 newborns in the letrozole group (2.4%) and in 19 of 397 newborns in the CC group(4.8%). The major malformation rate in the letrozole group was 1.2% (6 of 514) and in the CC group was 3.0% (12 of 397). These differences did not reach statistical significance because of the relatively small sample size.”

Well then, it seems that clomid has a birth defect rate that is at leat equal to that of Femara, and yet Clomid is used much more and without and warnings. The point being that the early small study was not informative enough and Femara seems safe to use, at least as safe as Clomid. Now this second study was not perfect either, but it was bigger and better than the first.

These are not the only studies published on Femara. There have been dozens all showing that the drug can be very effective and none others have shown an increase in birth defects.

Why would the drug company want to sell Femara if there is controversy over its safety?

As we discussed previously, Femara is a medication that blocks estrogen production, which is very helpful for many women with breast cancer. Most women have the type of breast cancer that grows faster in the presence of estrogen. Blocking the body’s ability to produce estrogen using Femara can significantly slow the growth of the tumor. This is why the company produces the drug. Unfortunately, there is a tremendous market for such a product.

On the other hand, the fertility business is comparatively very small and it is associated with very large liability risks. Even if the data relating the drug to birth defects is poor, I can see why the company would want to protect itself from potentially crippling birth defect lawsuits.

The good news is that the drug is available and a licensed MD can prescribe any drug “off label”, as long as there is good evidence that the drug is helpful and there is no harm.

Tons of drugs are used off label. One fertility example is Lupron for endometriosis. This drug is mostly used to treat men with prostate cancer as it lowers testosterone levels which may help restrict tumor growth. Lupron is also used in women with endometriosis because it lowers estrogen levels, and endometriosis needs estrogen to grow. Many women take it and the literature is loaded with scientific articles supporting its use in medical studies. And yet, Lupron it not FDA approved for the treatment of endometriosis. (For those of you thinking ahead, yes Femara is used by some to treat endometriosis). Another example is the use of antiepileptic drugs to treat anxiety and depression. Believe me; the list goes on and on.

So where does this all take us?
1) Femara works for the induction of ovulation.
2) Femara should not be given during pregnancy.
3) Femara does not thin the lining of the uterus as may Clomid
4) Femara is relatively new and associated with more warnings.

It is the last statement that makes doctors understandably nervous about using it, especially when there is a close alternative (Clomid) that has been around since the 1960’s.

As time has gone by, I have used Femara more and more, but still use Clomid first. As more time passes and more studies are done, this may change, and it is possible that Femara may become the first line treatment over Clomid for all fertility doctors. Importantly, no one yet has proven that Femara leads to a higher pregnancy rate than Clomid.

Thanks for reading and don’t forget to read the disclaimer from 5.17.06.

Dr. Licciardi

References:

  • Tulandi T, Martin J, Al-Fadhli R, Kabli N, Forman R, Hitkari J, Librach C, Greenblatt E, Casper RF. Congenital malformations among 911 newborns conceived after infertility treatment with letrozole or clomiphene citrate. Fertil Steril. 2006 Jun;85(6):1761-5.
  • Fisher SA, Reid RL, Van Vugt DA, Casper RF. A randomized double-blind comparison of the effects of clomiphene citrate and the aromatase inhibitor letrozole on ovulatory function in normal women. Fertil Steril. 2002 Aug;78(2):280-5.
  • Legro RS, Kunselman AR, Brzyski RG, Casson PR, Diamond MP, Schlaff WD, Christman GM, Coutifaris C, Taylor HS, Eisenberg E, Santoro N, Zhang H; NICHD Reproductive Medicine Network. The Pregnancy in Polycystic Ovary Syndrome II (PPCOS II) trial: rationale and design of a double-blind randomized trial of clomiphene citrate and letrozole for the treatment of infertility in women with polycystic ovary syndrome. Contemp Clin Trials. 2012 May;33(3):470-81.

35 responses to “Clomid vs Letrozole: The Last Words”

  1. Karen says:

    It’s amazing the timing of this post. I’m currently experiencing my third miscarriage in the last year. I have a 6yr old daughter which I carried with no problems. Pregnancy 1 before her was a missed miscarriage and the three this year have all been spontaneous at 5-6wks.

    All blood work,tests, etc show me and my husband are totally fine. The Dr has suggested Letrozole and I’m concerned about using intervention considering that I have been able to get pregnant.

    Will Letrozole actually increase my odds of carrying a baby? I’m guessing it’s because we would know for sure when ovulation occurs and guarantee a long enough luteal phase but I’m not sure.
    I would love more insight on this medication.

  2. iqbaluzmi says:

    HCG diets progress is positive because of natural hormone that burns the extra fat from the body and uses it for body energy.

    hcg buy online

  3. robert says:

    i like this blog…
    Transport & Logistics Jobs | Careers & Recruitment at Jobscharger.com
    http://www.jobscharger.com/JobIndustry/Transport-Logistics-38-.html

  4. This blog is a good one! Its original, thanks for the info! Is there a way I can tell my people about this post.

  5. Mel says:

    Any thoughts on Day 5 transfers of Morulas? Thats all we had… and just wondering what to expect. They were both 8 cell on day 3 and “looked good” at that point. Thanks,

  6. Anonymous says:

    One thing you don’t mention is the clearance tome of each medicine. From what my RE said letrozole clears out of the body within days, whereas clomide takes weeks. Thoughts?

  7. I am very entertain of all the great facts you shared in this blog.
    Thanks!

  8. sammy says:

    Great Post KEEP IT UP
    I’ve been using HOME CHECK OVULATION TEST KIT for a long time and I still get butterflies when that little smiley shows his face. 🙂 I got one from the internet by searching on Google HOME CHECK OVULATION KIT it was great!

  9. Georgette says:

    How often is clomid your first-line drug for women over 35, vs. Femara?

  10. Georgette says:

    Karen- with your mc history, you should look into immunology testing. Check out the work of Dr. Braverman.

  11. Anonymous says:

    I found this clinically researched system that is backed by 65,000+ hours of alternative medicine expertise with holistic and Chinese medicine research for getting pregnant quickly and naturally. This appears to be a unique and powerful Infertility healing system, which very few women even know exists. It is here
    http://81-classic-collegiate-classes.com/

  12. Heather says:

    Hi i’m Heather! I have a question for you! Please email me 🙂
    HeatherVonSJ[at]gmail[dot]com

  13. e cigarette says:

    Hi.I read this post two times. I like it so much, please try to keep posting.Let me introduce other material that may be good for our community.

  14. ipf says:

    Thanks for sharing a idea….Great post and informative
    IVF Mexico

  15. Home - Check says:

    Great Post KEEP IT UP
    I’ve been using HOME CHECK OVULATION TEST KIT for a long time and I still get butterflies when that little smiley shows his face. 🙂 I got one from the internet by searching on Google HOME CHECK OVULATION KIT it was great!

  16. amit says:

    Thanks for great information you write it very clean. I am very lucky to get this tips from you

    Fertility Clinic Scotland,

  17. Maureen says:

    Dr. Jane Semple, MA, ND is a Naturopathic Doctor practicing out of Cleveland, OH. A few years ago, she cured herself of Parkinson Disease symptoms using safe, all natural methods. Dr. Semple founded the Alternative Healing Institute to bring training for alternative therapies to individuals and medical professionals. She develops and teaches continuing education courses for those in the medical field. Dr. Semple is an active member of the American Naturopathic Medical Association, the Association of Nutritional Consultants, American Botanical Council and Coalition for Natural Health. She has authored several Woodland titles, including Alzheimer Disease, Blood Pressure, Cholesterol & Inflammation, Fertility, HPV and Cervical Dysplasia,Parkinson Disease and Influenza: Epidemics, Pandemics and Bird Flu. Her book High Blood Pressure: A Naturopathic Approach can be purchased at http://www.amazon.com/ and http://​www.woodlandpublishing.com/. Her website is http://www.mynsp.com/​drjanesemple/index.aspx. She also has a You Tube video explaining about Fertility. It can be viewed at http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=V4EgbLipCO8.

  18. Maureen says:

    This comment has been removed by the author.

  19. It feels great to drop by here on your site. Lots of information i have gathered here. Thanks for providing!

  20. Many people ask whether chiropractors can help infertile women. The short answer is yes, spinal adjustments can aid fertility issues. The doctor’s explanation is that adjustments ensure that the nerves which send signals to the ovaries and other reproductive organs are transmitting properly.

  21. anu verma says:

    Great Post KEEP IT UP
    I’ve been using OVULATION PREDICTOR for a long time and I still get butterflies when that little smiley shows his face. 🙂 I got one from the internet by searching on Google HOME CHECK OVULATION TEST KIT it was great!

  22. What about using acupuncture instead of drugs? Seems that there is some danger associated to these “fertility” drugs, whereas a lifestyle change may be more what is needed.

  23. Shannon says:

    Can everyone spread the word and help this woman out? It seems a really good cause! Here is the blog I found it on: http://makethisgoviral.wordpress.com/

    and here is the actual place to donate:

    http://gogetfunding.com/project/desperate-for-a-baby!-surrogacy-in-california-is-my-only-option!

  24. ivfmexico says:

    Thanks for sharing a idea….Great post and informative
    fertility doctor Mexico

  25. Anonymous says:

    Hi,

    My name is Michal Munk and I am pursuing a doctoral degree in clinical psychology at Fairleigh Dickinson University. As part of my dissertation I am researching the relationship between infertility, depression and body image in women, specifically as related to the differences between women with primary (unable to conceive and maintain a first pregnancy) and secondary (unable to conceive and maintain a pregnancy subsequent to having at least one child) infertility. I hope that findings from this study will eventually help develop better psychotherapy treatments for women with infertility.

    Females between the ages of 18-50, who are currently infertile (have had unprotected sex for at least 12 months with no successful pregnancy), and have no adopted/step child(ren) are eligible to participate in this study. The study entails completing questionnaires either online (https://www.surveymonkey.com/s/YCBQ35D), or by hard-copy upon request (call: 347-766-3798), and may be completed in 20-30 minutes. Participation is voluntary and confidentiality will be maintained. For each person who completes the survey, 2$ will be donated to RESOLVE: The National Infertility Association. This study has been approved by the FDU IRB (2/17/12).

    Feel free to contact me with any further questions about this study. I may be reached at 347-766-3798 or michalm@student.fdu.edu.

    Thank you for your time and consideration.

    Michal Munk, M.A.
    Clinical Psychology
    Fairleigh Dickinson University

  26. sammy says:

    How to get Pregnant
    I’ve been using OVULATION PREDICTOR for a long time and I still get butterflies when that little smiley shows his face. 🙂 I got one from the internet by searching on Google HOME CHECK OVULATION TEST KIT it was great!

  27. Anonymous says:

    Hi I was just browsing the internet and came upon this site. I am 28 yrs old never been pregnant. Me and my boyfriend have been together for 8 yrs on and off. We have been on for the past yr and are ttc. We never used protection but I wasn’t concerned bcus I figured it wasn’t our time but now recent events make me think otherwise. I haven’t had a menstrual since jan 5 and that is very abnormal for me I have always been regular anywhere from a 26-28 day cycle. I took home pregnacy test came back neg. Went to the docs urine and blood test neg. Idk is there anybody that went or is currently going through something like this?

  28. rahul says:

    Thanks for great information you write it very clean. I am very lucky to get this tips from you

    Fertility Clinic Scotland

  29. ED blog says:

    Now HCG diets are very actual specially from the point of view of burning fat

  30. Mike says:

    There are certainly a lot more details to take into consideration, but thanks for sharing this post.
    Sperm Donors

  31. Sally says:

    Great blog with lots of great fertility info! Thanks especially for this detailed posting on Femara and Clomid.

  32. Aubrey says:

    Thank you for such a wonderful blog. I was wondering if you have ever worked with a female Kallmann’s patient before? I was able to get pregnant twice (once through IUI and once through IVF). Both ended being “biochemical.” My Doctor seems to think it’s bad luck, but I can’t help but think there is more to it. Any insight would be appreciated.

  33. e-cigarette says:

    I love your post and also your blog; it is very well structured and has a lot of useful info.

  34. anu verma says:

    Home-Check Instant Ovulation Test is designed to detect the surge in Luteinizing Hormone (LH). The body always makes small amounts of LH but prior to ovulation it makes far more. This test device will detect the LH surge which happens in the middle of your menstrual cycle, about 1 -1.5 days before ovulation.

  35. Many women who would want to have their own baby would try anything even though they would have to take medications. The safety of these medications are needed to reviewed because there might be some effects on the baby. Even birth defects are possible or multiple births.

Leave a Reply